How Best to Assess? (So Much to Assess and So Little Time)

This past week I had the opportunity to take over a portion of the teaching day in my 1^st grade dyad placement.  I taught an hour-long math lesson introducing money (nickels and pennies) that incorporated prior lessons on addition, equations and counting on.  I also led an interactive read-aloud on Miss Spider’s Tea Party by David Kirk, highlighting (among other things) the difference between fiction and non-fiction, noticing patterns (rhyme and sequential numbers) and making predictions.  I feel fairly confident that most of the students understood the lesson objectives but without an assessment that provides data on each individual student (such as a quiz or one-on-one conversation) it is very difficult to know.  Most informal written assessments (worksheets, etc.) for which we, of course, do not require students to use “privacy cubbies” of some sort, have the flaw of students being able to easily look at and copy each other’s work.  Although one-on-one conferencing gives us the best data, time rarely allows it.  One of the most surprising things I have learned about teaching is the importance of almost constant formative assessment to inform our teaching, especially with regard to providing extra support for those students who need it.  I have learned that assessment can be as simple as having a group discussion of a book or math lesson, or looking over children’s shoulders as they work on an assignment.  However, this usually does not capture accurate data on every student in the class.  I feel that in my teaching this past week I was able to get a good general “pulse” of where the class was, but I see that I will have to be a lot more conscientious in seeking out formative assessment data on students who might otherwise “fall through the cracks.”  I like Jean’s suggestion of carrying around a notebook at all times that has the students’ names listed down the side to take impromptu notes on their work and our conversations with them.  Other ideas?  What assessments are easiest for you to do "on the fly?"  Which are most effective for you?  Which do you find more difficult to carry out?

Really Seeing Our New Students

As we are diving into our new placements and getting to know a new set of students,  I am reminded of what we learned a few quarters ago from William Ayers' book To Teach.  In his chapter titled Seeing the Student he admonishes us not to fall into the trap of defining students by their incompetencies.  He reminds us that "labels are limiting . . . they conceal more than they reveal (p. 42)."  He goes on to note "the deficiencies list tells you almost nothing about me . . . it doesn't offer you any insight or clues into how you might engage me in a journey of learning or how you might invite me into your classroom as a student (p.44)."  I am reminded of this because before meeting some of the students in my new classroom for the first time, I heard them characterized by others with some pretty limiting labels that negatively colored my first impressions of them.  Without at first realizing it, I found I was predisposed to look for negative behaviors and incompetencies in these students.  Luckily, I quickly caught myself and have since been making a concerted effort to get to know the competencies and unique positive qualities of these "problem" students so that I can ascertain how best to connect with them and teach them.  I need to find out what they do know and what is important to them.  Little by little I am learning more about them which is helping me to help them more each day.  As an added bonus, with a more positive outlook, I find I am enjoying the class even more -- and I think they are too. 

Deciphering the Curriculum

What I am puzzling about in my placement this week is how to get enough of a handle on a whole new set of curricula in order to be able to have an authentic teaching experience in such a short amount of time in our current "mini" dyad placements.  I am curious as to how other teachers and teachers-in-training approach this challenge, whether it be for a new job or a short-term assignment such as the one we're facing, or even as a substitute.  The curricula for math and reading, in particular, are so robust and multi-faceted that it is hard to find a point of entry.  I'd like to start dipping my toes in the water by implementing basic pieces and then layering on more complexity as I master the various tools available.

  

The fact that the curriculum authors give you more resources than you can possibly use is both a blessing and a curse.  It presents great flexibility and also great confusion.  I find myself wishing for a "Getting Started" or "Quick Start" guide like you typically get with a new camera or laptop computer that simplifies the multitude of options and features into a manageable portion with which to get started.  Certainly I will work with our cooperating teacher to decipher the choices, but I wonder if anyone has any "tricks of the trade" in how to best approach a new curriculum. 

Back to School (& Back to Blogging)

Our back-to-school "September Experience" officially came to a close on Friday and as I  must now also get back to blogging, that experience seems an appropriate thing to blog about.  I learned to put into practice so many things that we have been learning -- from backwards mapping a lesson (on latitude and longitude!) to building a classroom community from a group of 28 very diverse 4th and 5th graders.  

Borrowing from my Intro to Field Experience Final Reflection . . . September Experience was amazing, exhausting, enlightening, frustrating, humbling and inspiring.  I learned that 4th and 5th graders try to act older than they are but are really still kids at heart.  I learned that with 28 kids in a classroom, everything takes a lot longer than you think it will.  I learned that, more often than not, things do not go exactly as planned.  I learned that even the toughest kids have a soft side and even the quietest kids have amazing things to say.  I learned that what we say is often less important than how we say it.  I learned that special needs kids are not a burden, but a gift.  I learned how easy it is to inadvertently ignore the quiet, middle-of-the-road kids.  I learned that there are an amazing array of teaching styles and that I need to learn to better appreciate and work with and learn from all of them.  Most importantly, I learned that I cannot possibly learn all of the things that I want to learn in just one year of student teaching!

I wrote that reflection before my final day of September Experience when my cooperating teacher was out for planning meetings all day and I took control of the class (with a sub to assist, of course).  In so doing, I learned a few additional things among which are that it takes a lot longer to plan a lesson than to teach a lesson and that managing transitions is going to be a vital skill to master!!

Food Journal Reflection

Keeping a food journal for our Health & Fitness methods class was not hard for me as I have kept food and activity journals on and off for the last five or six years.  In 2006 I found myself weighing more than I ever had in my life and I became determined to turn it around.  I put myself on a 1200-1500 calorie per day diet and began a more regular exercise routine.  During this time I religiously kept a food and exercise log and I succeeded in losing 30 pounds in about six months.  Give or take five pounds, I’ve largely been able to keep it off.  Writing down food and exercise information each day really keeps my good (and bad) habits in the forefront of my mind.  It doesn’t prevent slips and lapses, but it helps me get back on track more quickly afterwards.  I think I am a pretty healthy role model as I subscribe to diet and exercise habits that are well balanced and allow for occasional splurges in eating as well as occasional rest days from exercise.  The most important thing is to eat a well-balanced diet (no crazy fads), to allow yourself small indulgences, and to not beat yourself up for having a bad day (or week) every once in a while. 

For this class, after one week we were asked to set a goal for the remainder of the class.  I set two goals for myself – to increase the intensity of my daily exercise at least three times a week and to get more sleep.  Sleep has been a big issue for me since starting this program and in particular this quarter with our classes all concentrated in the middle of the week.  I find myself wanting to spend time with my family during dinner and early evening and then end up “burning the midnight oil” trying to get my school work done later in the evening and well after they’ve gone to bed.  This not only makes me tired in general but also has a definite (and negative) impact on my eating and exercise habits.  The more tired I am, the less motivated I am to push myself when exercising and the more apt I am to snack between meals to keep my energy up.  Nevertheless, I did force myself to do less walking and more running when taking my 11-month old lab puppy for his morning exercise before school each day and once I got going it really did make me feel better.  I also learned that it was easier to stretch the length of my running intervals in manageable increments rather than setting overly ambitious goals for myself that set me up for failure.

I think keeping food/activity/sleep journals is a great way to increase students’ awareness of their health habits.  It’s amazing how I found myself giving second thought before taking a cookie or other not-so-healthy choice because I didn’t want to have to record it or how the guilt from skipping a day of exercise is multiplied by seeing that blank spot in the journal the following day.  Keeping a health journal is a great way of making us more aware of our choices and also accountable to ourselves for committing to goals and recording progress towards those goals.  This could easily be stretched into an interdisciplinary activity for our students.  Math can be incorporated by calculating things such as calories and BMI and also by graphing progress towards goals.  Science can be incorporated in learning about the body’s needs for a balanced diet, knowledge about the “quality” of calories (nutrient-rich vs. “empty”) and the physiological importance of exercise and sleep.  

Brains

I held a human brain in my hands today!  Never in my wildest dreams did I think I would ever utter that sentence.  I was not even looking forward to seeing it let alone touching it, but I'm glad I did.  It was about the size of a head of cauliflower but really much heavier than I expected.  I also learned a lot about the brain from our micro-teaching lesson today like, for instance, that it is made up largely of water and fat and that carbohydrates and hydration are important in keeping a healthy brain . . . who knew?!  

Information from Anonymity

An interesting takeaway from class today for me was the power of using anonymity to increase the accuracy of information garnered from a group.  This strategy was used by both a micro-teaching team and by our teacher.  In the first instance we were simulating a sixth grade sex education class and the tool was to offer slips of paper that could be filled out anonymously with questions and placed in a box for the teacher to address during the following day's class.  It seems there would still be a glitch in that students might look around and see who is filling out slips and who isn't.  I would solve this by asking everyone in the class to take a slip and write something -- even if it is just "Have a good weekend" -- so that no one feels self-conscious about taking a slip and no one knows who wrote the questions that are discussed in the following class session.  In the second instance our teacher asked us to fill out an anonymous survey about our level of comfort with our preparation to teach various aspects of sex education.  There were ten questions each of which was answered on a scale of one to ten.  She then collected the surveys, mixed them up and redistributed them.  She placed the numbers one through ten on the floor and as each question was read we stood on/near the number reported on the survey (not our own) that we were now holding.  We were able to quickly see how the class was feeling without putting individuals on the spot.  Both were great uses of anonymity to overcome reluctance to honestly share one's opinion or to ask sensitive or embarrassing questions.